It’s Not That Zohran Mamdani Is Stupid. It’s Much Worse Than That.

Nov 18, 2026 6:51 PM
Premium
Advertisement
It’s Not That Zohran Mamdani Is Stupid. It’s Much Worse Than That.
AP Photo/Stephanie Rojas
VIP

Is Zohran Mamdani an idiot? It’s hard to escape that impression, but he is to all appearances an articulate young man who is deeply committed to his cherished beliefs. He is not someone who appears to be limited intellectually and easily led; on the contrary, he has repeatedly shown himself to be glib and adept at deflecting criticism and hostile questions, often by making a hash of the truth. 

So why would he do something that so obviously will bring harm to New Yorkers and likely make him suffer politically as well, as he will almost certainly be blamed for the inevitable failure of his latest scheme? Is he really not as smart as he tries to appear? Indeed he isn’t, but that’s not why he is disbanding the Strategic Response Group, the NYPD unit tasked with responding to riots and thwarting jihad terror attacks. It’s not that he’s stupid. It’s much worse than that.

Mamdani announced Monday:

…I am disbanding the SRG. SRG was tasked with both counterterrorism enforcement and protest response. Those are not the same, and they should be separated. Government has a responsibility to both protect New Yorkers' constitutional rights and keep our communities safe. Those priorities are not in conflict. They are intertwined. 

That's why we are creating a community dialogue and de-escalation division within the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety, to prepare for and respond to protests through dialogue and engagement. This will not be a uniformed police unit. It will be made up of civilians, without weapons or arrest powers. A First Amendment support team within the police department, called FAST, will also engage in dialogue and de-escalation at protests as we build out the new civilian division. FAST will remain as a liaison team, while CDDD takes the lead in engaging with New Yorkers. 

Trained officers can be called upon to come make arrests, including for those engaging in civil disobedience. We both know something about that. There will be no long guns, tear gas, kettling, or pepper spray used as crowd control tactics during First Amendment activities….

If Zohran Mamdani is not stupid, why would he do something that is so obviously not going to work? Can you imagine a terrorist standing down because an unarmed, anti-masculine, gay flag-waving leftist shows up and lectures him about inclusivity and respect for diversity? Do you think rioters will stop shattering windows and kicking in doors because a blue-haired community dialogue coordinator will invite them to sit down and talk out their concerns?

What Zohran Mamdani is doing, as Catherine Salgado pointed out here, is instituting a policy that will actively endanger the people he was elected to protect and to serve. Only someone with absolutely zero experience of the real world could possibly believe that unarmed negotiators could possibly defuse crisis situations involving people who are determined to engage in destruction on as large a scale as possible.

Now, socialists are notoriously impervious to evidence. If they could learn from history, there would be no more socialists. But this is something even worse than that. Mamdani is actively working to destroy New York. He can’t impose a new Muslim socialist order unless and until the old order is destroyed, and he is working hard now to destroy it. 

The Bolsheviks and other Russian revolutionaries had to drive the czar from power before they could create the Soviet state. They encouraged, and often created, the chaos in the czarist state in order to weaken the existing order and hasten its replacement. The founding figure of Soviet Russia, V. I. Lenin, shrugged off the bloodshed and senseless killing of innocent human beings by uttering the famous adage, “If you want to make an omelet, you have to break some eggs.”

Related: Mamdani Defines Socialism, and Wow, It Sounds Great, But...

Likewise in the shah’s Iran, the Islamic revolutionaries engaged in numerous acts of mayhem to hasten the fall of the existing regime and the coming of Khomeini’s Islamic revolution. And when the Islamic regime came to power in that country, it followed the pattern of leftist revolutions the world over, and instituted a reign of terror. Innocent people were injured and killed, but it was all for a greater good: the imposition of the Islamic order.

Mamdani also believes that what he is doing, though it will endanger New Yorkers and get innocent people killed, is all for a greater good: the imposition of a Marxist/Islamic authoritarian government in the city. Democrats nationwide are pursuing the same vision for the rest of us.

Comments

Recommended

Trending on PJ Media Videos