You're probably familiar with the Wave Model that helps explain the history of terrorism.
The late UCLA political science professor David C. Rapoport used the metaphor of "waves" instead of "eras" or "periods" because there is really no set beginning and end of a wave. They eventually merge into one another.
In 1999, Rapoport first introduced his "wave" model in an essay in the larger volume Encyclopedia of Violence, Peace and Conflict. After 9/11, he updated the piece and published “The Fourth Wave: September 11 in the History of Terrorism” in December 2001, followed by an expanded version in 2004, under the title “The Four Waves of Modern Terrorism.”
Terrorism studies now use the "wave model" as the primary means of understanding the phenomenon.
Rapoport divided the history of terrorism into four waves.
- Anarchist Wave, 1879-1920s
- Anticolonial Wave, 1919-1960s
- New Left Wave, 1960s-1990s
- Religious Wave, 1979-2020s?
Academia began beating the drum for a "Fifth Wave" of terrorism, citing the "right-wing" as the villains. In a way, it was pathetic. Anxious to avoid what everyone else could see, left-wing academics cherry-picked right-wing attacks, giving them far more importance and impact than the radical left's acts of violence.
After Barack Obama won his election in 2008, he sought to end the "war on terror" and make it a "war on domestic terrorism." The words "jihad" and "Islamism" were banished from the lexicon of the U.S. government. Recall that Obama tried to minimize the threat of ISIS by referring to them as "the JV team." Two years later, after half of Syria and a quarter of Iraq had become the new "caliphate," Obama was forced to send troops to the region to prevent further gains by an organized terrorist state.
In 2020, the journal Perspectives on Terrorism published “Right-Wing Terror: A Fifth Global Wave?” by Vincent A. Auger; in 2021, it published “A New Wave of Terrorism? A Comparative Analysis of the Rise of Far-Right Terrorism” by Jonathan Collins. That same year, the journal Terrorism and Political Violence published “Right-Wing Waves: Applying the Four Waves Theory to Transnational and Transhistorical Right-Wing Threat Trends” by Amber Hart. Many others followed the trend.
Meanwhile, the George Floyd riots were burning down American cities, Antifa was targeting conservatives, and America's youth began marching for Palestinians.
So what is the "Fifth Wave of Terrorism"? "The Fifth Wave of terrorism is anti-Zionist, antisemitic, anti-law enforcement, anti-capitalist, anti-conservative, anti-Republican, and anti-Trump," writes A.J. Caschetta. "Everything that its adherents favor is defined by what they oppose."
I would add to that list "anti-modernity." Many of these same violent, left-wing elements are behind opposition (and attacks) on data centers, and threats against AI company executives have become commonplace.
In what many consider his most important (presidential?) speech, on July 16, Secretary of State Marco Rubio spoke to the Ministerial on the Resurgence of Political Terrorism and told law enforcement and intelligence leaders from 60 nations that left-wing political violence has surged to unprecedented levels.
In his July speech, Rubio recounted U.S. success fighting Fourth Wave groups: “we destroyed the ISIS Caliphate; we killed al-Baghdadi, and al-Zawahiri, and bin Laden. And we built intelligence and law enforcement systems capable of anticipating and stopping attacks before the public even hears about them.” But he stopped short of announcing that the Fourth Wave is over, acknowledging that while “the threat has not disappeared ... [it] has been severely diminished.”
Instead, Rubio focused on the Third Wave, likening today’s atmosphere to the era when the American Weather Underground, the Italian Red Brigades, the German Red Army Faction, the Japanese Red Army, the Greek November 17 Organization, the Peruvian Shining Path, the French Action Directe, and others terrorized the world. “Between 1970 and 1980,” Rubio said, “93 percent of terrorist attacks in the West came from the far extremist left.”
He suggested that the new wave was a reiteration of this old one. “It may wear various different slogans and ideologies across place and time,” he said, but "[i]t is always the same.”
Caschetta points out that the Fifth Wave is much more than a simple repeat or augmentation of the Third Wave. It is, in fact, "an amalgamation of all four waves, under a left-wing umbrella. Perhaps we should call it the New, New Left Wave."
The anarchist roots of Antifa, as well as the anti-capitalist tenor of extremist rhetoric, along with the "decolonization" movement and the antisemitic violence against Jews, combine to form the Fifth Wave.
The most disturbing part of the Fifth Wave is that it is moving the "Overton Window" that includes formerly unacceptable beliefs into the mainstream. The reaction to the death of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was cheered by many on the left, especially younger liberals in a shockingly macabre demonstration of the breakdown of civil society.
Even Senate Minority Leader Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) has stepped over the line of propriety and civil discourse. In March 2020, Schumer gave a chilling warning to Supreme Court justices at a demonstration on the steps of the Supreme Court building when he said ominously, “I want to tell you Gorsuch, I want to tell you Kavanaugh, you have released the whirlwind and you will pay the price. You won’t know what hit you if you go forward with these awful decisions.”
The Democratic Socialists of America and their eliminationist rhetoric about capitalism, the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the shoot-up of Republican lawmakers at practice for the Congressional baseball game, the George Floyd riots, the murder of a young Jewish couple in Washington, D.C., all garnered praise from a disturbingly large number of people on the political left. Of course, the sorrow expressed by leftists that Donald Trump has escaped death twice is the surest sign that opponents of the left are now fair game for assassination.
They are moving the Overton Window in the direction of violent nihilism. It's going to get worse before it gets better.