NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya Pens a Letter Asking for Retraction of the 'Proximal Cause' Paper

Nov 21, 2026 12:31 AM
Premium
Advertisement
NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya Pens a Letter Asking for Retraction of the 'Proximal Cause' Paper
AP Photo/Allison Robbert
VIP

Jay Bhattacharya, head of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), is well-positioned to keep the fight going to clear the names of the dozens of researchers and scientists, including himself, who suffered for the apostasy of trying to counter the conventional wisdom on COVID-19.

In October of 2020, as the COVID-19 virus was wreaking havoc on schools, offices, and businesses, several dozen prominent scientists, including Bhattacharya, wrote an open letter to the scientific community, in which they dared to propose an alternative to the total shutdown of society. "Focused Protection" would protect the vulnerable (diabetics, people with heart and breathing problems, and those with immune diseases) and save us from the worst effects of the shutdown. Those effects "include lower childhood vaccination rates, worsening cardiovascular disease outcomes, fewer cancer screenings and deteriorating mental health – leading to greater excess mortality in years to come, with the working class and younger members of society carrying the heaviest burden," the letter stated. "Keeping students out of school is a grave injustice," they added.

Bhattacharya suffered for his defiance. The "Twitter Files" revealed that Twitter had placed Bhattacharya on a secret "Trends Blacklist" shortly after he joined the platform in August 2021. This algorithmic restriction prevented his tweets from ever appearing in Twitter's trending topics, regardless of how much engagement they received. Also, released emails later showed that then-NIH Director Francis Collins emailed Anthony Fauci, calling Bhattacharya and his co-authors "three fringe epidemiologists" and urging a "quick and devastating published take down" of their premises.

Bhattacharya was excluded from major academic panels, faced hostility from colleagues at Stanford (including a faculty petition condemning his work with the DeSantis administration), and saw his research and expert witness testimony heavily criticized by mainstream epidemiologists and several judges. 

The academic and professional pushback was never warranted. Bhattacharya, a respected public health expert and epidemiologist, offered an alternative that might avoid economic and academic catastrophe.

But Bhattacharya's greatest sin was his criticism of the "Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2" letter published in Nature Medicine, which totally rejected any possibility that a lab leak led to the pandemic. Both prior to and during his tenure as Director of NIH, he has called for the paper's investigation and retraction.

"The paper attributed to five leading virologists, but not then-top NIH officials Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins, led news organizations and public health experts to dismiss evidence that pointed to a lab leak," says Politico. In fact, it was much worse than a simple scientific disagreement. 

There is some evidence that Anthony Fauci, head of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), and Francis Collins, then head of NIH, had considerable input into the final draft of the paper. Congressional investigations reveal that both officials were given drafts of the paper and their contributions may have swayed the other authors to alter their opinions.

In a letter to Nature Medicine on Wednesday, Bhattacharya "asks the editors to investigate the paper’s authorship, correct the record or retract it," says Politico.

 “The NIH is presenting the question of whether the byline and acknowledgments accurately reflect the individuals who contributed substantively to the conception, drafting, revision, or publication of the manuscript,” Bhattacharya wrote.

Politico:

Bhattacharya’s letter cites congressional investigative findings showing Fauci and Collins were included in communications related to “The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2” paper and were sent drafts. It also cites the involvement of Jeremy Farrar, a biologist who was advising the British government at the time, in organizing a Feb. 1, 2020 meeting where concerns about the Covid origin were discussed. The meeting was the starting point for the drafting of the article. Farrar later provided comments and helped facilitate the paper’s publication. Farrar did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Bhattacharya wants the Nature Medicine editors to provide within 30 days a planned scope of their review and a timetable.

“The proximal origin” paper’s listed authors were Kristian Andersen, Andrew Rambaut, W. Ian Lipkin, Edward Holmes and Robert F. Garry.

In Slack messages, Andersen and others were expressing exactly the opposite opinion about a lab leak, both before, during, and after publication. "They still thought a lab leak was 'friggin likely', in the words of Andersen.

In an op-ed in The Telegraph, science writer Matt Ridley calls the plot to discredit the lab leak theory a "Crime Against Science." 

"In a career as a science writer that spans more than four decades, I have never seen an alleged case of scientific malpractice as influential," he writes. 

The Telegraph:

Worse than all that, congressional investigations have uncovered records strongly indicating that three of the most senior medical scientists in the world, Francis Collins (Bhattacharya's predecessor as head of the National Institutes of Health), Anthony Fauci (head of National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases) and Jeremy Farrar (head of the Wellcome Trust) had not only seen the paper before publication, but – according to a House Select Subcommittee report – had prompted its authors to write it in the first place, had reviewed it and even suggested alterations in wording. Fauci referred to the paper from the White House podium, giving no hint of his own role in it.

It's been suggested that the scientists tried to hide the story of a lab leak because they knew they had funded illegal gain-of-function research at the Wuhan lab that may have led to the accidental release of the COVID virus. That possibility cannot yet be dismissed. It would help if we got some clarity from Fauci and Collins, but given the possible destruction of their reputations, it's not going to happen. 

Also for our VIPs: It’s Trump’s, Xi’s, and Putin’s World Now, and Europe Is Just Living in It

Comments

Recommended

Trending on PJ Media Videos