How Democrats Think They Can Achieve Amnesty Under Trump

Nov 19, 2026 2:30 PM
Premium
Advertisement
How Democrats Think They Can Achieve Amnesty Under Trump
Townhall Media/Julio Rosas
VIP

Democrats are about to control both chambers of Congress, and there's no doubt their primary objective with that majority is lawfare. They intend to investigate Trump officials and allies in hopes of eventually finding a crime they can use as a pretext for impeachment.

But lawfare is only half the agenda.

Democrats may have the majority, but Donald Trump is still president, and they can't override his veto. Not with blatantly partisan legislation, anyway. So it's worth watching how they plan to push their priorities anyway, because it broadcasts exactly what they intend to do the next time they hold the White House and both chambers of Congress.

Consider the "Protect Our Neighbors Act," which freshman Rep. Lateefah Simon (D-Calif.) is introducing on Thursday, as ABC News first reported. Reps. John Garamendi (D-Calif.), Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), and Juan Vargas (D-Calif.) are co-sponsoring it.

The bill targets final orders of removal. An immigration judge or the authorities issue the order, and it becomes final when the appeals have run their course or the time limit has expired. At that point, the person can be removed.

Deportation doesn't happen immediately, though.

A person can have deferred action, have a stay of removal, or be the subject of a case in court, which can delay the process for many years. Under current law, a final removal order never expires. Simon's bill would change that. An order would lapse 10 years after it was issued, as long as the person stayed in the U.S. the entire time and had no criminal conviction. Once the order lapses, that person could seek lawful permanent residency.

That's a radical change.

And that's where the numbers come in. In February, then-acting ICE Director Todd Lyons told lawmakers that about 1.6 million people in the U.S. have final deportation orders. Every one of them who dodges removal for a decade with a clean record becomes a candidate for a green card. In other words, this is amnesty for illegals who haven't been caught and deported yet.

The so-called safeguard is weak.

An immigration judge could renew an expired order only with "clear and convincing evidence" of a significant reason for delay, excluding administrative or funding issues, and proof that renewal serves the public interest. Since most delays stem from backlogs and budgets, the standard favors those facing removal, not the government.

ICYMI: Hakeem Jeffries Is Preparing to Go Full Stalin on the Entire MAGA Movement

Simon said deportation orders "need to be again turned off" for people who have done everything right for over 10 years. She's had discussions with the Democrat leaders and hopes for support from both parties.

Democrats think they're playing it smart here, but we know better.

They want us to believe this is a balanced approach that everyone can accept. Don’t buy it. Let’s not forget that when the Trump administration targeted killers and child rapists for deportation, Democrats defended the killers and rapists. Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) literally flew to El Salvador to have margaritas with deported illegal immigrant and MS-13 gang member Kilmar Abrego Garcia.

On top of that, left-wing judges have dismissed charges against illegal immigrants to avoid turning them over to ICE. If Democrats truly had distinguished between criminal illegal immigrants and the "good neighbors," they wouldn't have spent all this time defending the scum of the earth.

This legislation is a Trojan horse. The goal of this legislation is to halt deportations across the board while using the "good neighbor" label as political cover.

The endgame is political: securing future votes.

While the bill likely won't get a vote during the lame-duck session, it can and probably will come back in January under the new Congress. Trump would veto it, so the real test is whether enough Republicans fall for it to give Democrats a veto-proof majority.

That's the playbook.

It likely won’t work under Trump, but whatever they can't pass under this president, they’ll do the second a Democrat wins the White House again.

Comments

Recommended

Trending on PJ Media Videos