I'll be blunt. I'm not the kind of guy who tells you what you want to hear instead of the truth, and anyone who has read me for a while knows it. Plenty of influencers out there reflexively dismiss every poll they don't like. I hate that.
They've decided false hope beats an honest picture of what's happening.
I think that's a lousy strategy. It sets people up for disappointment, and it torches credibility that never comes back. So I'll only tell you what I actually believe. When polls claimed Kamala Harris was ahead in 2024, I told you they were B.S. because I knew they were, based on crosstabs that didn’t jibe with the toplines.
This year, I believe the GOP will outperform the polls again.
Can Republicans hold both the House and the Senate? The House is a harder sell. The Senate is a different story, and I'm confident Republicans will keep it.
My confidence has nothing to do with the "polls are wrong" mantra. Polling is an imperfect science, and we have enough data to know polls will miss by a certain margin. If history holds, we keep the Senate.
CNN's Harry Enten walked through the numbers on Friday, and at first glance they look grim for Republicans. Democrats lead the polling averages in Ohio by four points, Michigan by three, Texas by three, Maine by two, and Iowa by one. Kansas, which hasn't elected a Democrat to the Senate since 1932, is tied. Democrats likely need to win at least three of those races to flip the chamber.
"If these polls were exactly right, and that is that they match the result on Election Day, matches what the polling shows right now, the Democrats would, in fact, take control of the United States Senate," Enten told Sara Sidner. "The question is, are the results on election night going to match what the polling shows right now?"
History offers a pretty clear answer. Enten pulled the final polling averages, built from surveys taken in the last 21 days of each campaign, for Senate races decided by five points or fewer. On average, those aggregates missed the final result by 3.7 points. Nearly every race on the current map sits inside that window.
Recommended: Trump Accuses Cornyn, Rove of Sabotaging Paxton
"Polls are a tool. Poll aggregates are a tool," he explained. "When you have all of these close races, you have to keep this in mind."
The more important question is which direction the miss tends to break. Asked what happens if the error favors Republicans, Enten didn't sugarcoat it for his own side of the aisle.
"This, to me, is the big siren warning sign for Democrats right here. Because I know you feel like it's Lucy and the football," he said. "You've seen yourselves ahead before. And then Election Day, the votes are cast and counted and the Republicans come out ahead."
If Republicans beat their polling averages by 3.75 points, the map transforms. The GOP picks up wins in Maine, Michigan, Texas, Kansas, Iowa, and Alaska, and walks away with a 52-48 Senate majority.
"But I think we've seen this story a little bit before. And that is why this Senate map is still way too close to call," Enten added. "Republicans very much in the ball game."
🚨 JUST IN: CNN says Republicans HOLD CONTROL of the US Senate 52-48 if the average poll error occurs for Republicans THEY'D LOSE MICHIGAN. "The average error rate, off by 3.7 points!" "Siren warning for Democrats...if we get this average error rate...THIS is what we're talking about...Republicans would get 52 seats, Democrats would get 48." In 2024, Mike Rogers came within roughly 19,000 votes of winning Michigan. HE CAN DO IT THIS TIME The polls have underestimated Trump voters in every one of his elections. If they vote, we win. This is why ALL OF US in EVERY STATE need to vote no matter what Texas, Ohio, Alaska, Maine, Michigan, it's all winnable!
— Eric Daugherty (@EricLDaugh) October 16, 2026
The Democrats’ math requires the polls to be right in nearly every close race, all at once, in a country where Senate polling has routinely underestimated Republicans. The GOP needs only an ordinary polling miss in its favor. One of those scenarios asks for a miracle. The other asks history to repeat itself.
None of that means Republicans can coast to victory. Voters still have to show up, and a few weeks is plenty of time for the ground to shift. But the evidence points in one direction, and I'm comfortable saying where I think this ends.
