Reasonable people disagree about plenty of things in American politics. Take tax policy, immigration, or how big government should be. Those are legitimate debates where smart people can land in different places. Then there's the fight over whether biological men should compete against women in sports. The polling shows the public settled that question years ago, and only a small, vocal faction keeps pretending otherwise.
Gallup's latest survey, conducted in June 2025, found that 69% of Americans oppose letting men who "identify" as women compete in women's sports. That number continues a multi-year trend of declining public support for the practice. The same poll found that 69% of U.S. adults believe transgender athletes should compete only on teams matching their birth sex, and 66% say a person's birth sex, not their gender identity, belongs on government documents like passports and driver's licenses.
Here's where it gets interesting. Even Democrats aren't as unified as the media pretends.
“Each of these policies has broad support from about nine in 10 Republicans but only about four in 10 Democrats, while independents’ views are similar to the national averages,” explains Gallup. “A slim majority of Democrats (54%) believe people should be able to list their current gender identity on government documents, but fewer (45%) think transgender people should be able to play on sports teams that match their gender identity. Fourteen percent of Democrats are unsure where they stand on this question about transgender athletes.”
That's a party whose voters increasingly sense something is off, whatever their leaders keep insisting in public.
ICYMI: A Democrat Just Confessed the Midterms Could Be a Disaster for His Party
Make no mistake about it, this isn't a one-poll fluke. A New York Times/Ipsos poll from last year found that 79% of Americans believe men “should not be allowed to compete in women’s sports,” including 94% of Republicans, 67% of Democrats, and 64% of Independent voters. A recent survey from Napolitan News Service found opposition to males competing in female sports leagues at 63%, with just 20% in favor and 17% undecided. Even a majority of Democrats, 53%, opposed male participation.
In the realm of politics, that’s a consensus.
On top of that, most Americans understand exactly what's at stake. Nationally, 62% of voters say letting biological males compete would deny opportunities to biological female athletes, and 66% say it increases the chance of significant injury to women. Among daily political talkers, at least 75% admit male participation would deny opportunities to women and raise injury risk. And this same group still says biological males should be allowed to compete anyway.
So who's actually driving this fight? A small, radical slice of the left manufactured this "controversy," and the media have kept it alive by treating their fringe opinions as mainstream consensus. Nearly 70% of the country made up its mind years ago. The politicians and pundits who are still pretending this is an open question are performing for each other, long after the public settled the issue.
