On Nov. 16, 2006, Milton Friedman died, but he left behind a wealth of wise observations about freedom, economics, and government. Among them were criticisms of allowing government programs that would allegedly be temporary and of praising programs for stated intentions rather than actual results.
First is Friedman’s famous statement, “Nothing is so permanent as a temporary government program.” And again, he said, “One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.” Politicians demand credit whenever they announce some new program allegedly to deliver affordability or “free” transportation or homelessness assistance or medical care or humanitarian aid. They never want us to ask what the cost is to taxpayers, what the measurable results of the program are, and whether the government can most effectively and efficiently accomplish the goal. It’s the attitude that USAID must be good because it has “aid” in its abbreviation, even though it actually wasted money on drag shows and DEI propaganda.
It is a serious flaw in modern American politics that both Republicans and Democrats always start with the assumption that government should be involved in almost every aspect of society. Thus Republicans and Democrats (with a few exceptions) don’t argue about whether or not there should be federal regulation of and meddling in healthcare or education or airline travel, but simply about the degree of interference and regulation. This is completely different from the attitude that the Founding Fathers had and explains the thousands of unconstitutional government entities and programs that waste so much taxpayer money without actually improving Americans’ lives while encroaching on their freedoms.
Related: Bernie Wants a Healthcare ‘Solution’ Far Worse Than the Problem
Perhaps the most obvious example of this was the COVID-19 pandemic. There was no need for the government to have any national response to a virus with a 99% survival rate, and in the long run, arbitrary lockdown, masking, and vaccine policies caused a great deal more harm than good. But for some reason, almost everyone seemed to take it for granted that we had to have a national government response to the virus, even though it ought to have been obvious that any such response would crush our rights.
Now, I think, more conservatives are realizing what a disaster such an attitude is, but unfortunately, most Republican politicians haven’t learned their lesson. That ties into Friedman‘s other warning about how a government program is never temporary.
As an example of the difficulty of eradicating any government program, and therefore the danger of starting any such program, we can look to temporary protected status or TPS, which by its very name implies temporal briefness. And yet multiple groups, including Somalis, Haitians, and Syrians, had TPS for more than a decade, and Somalis for more than three decades. The Trump administration ended TPS for numerous groups, but guess what the incoming Democrat Congress is already planning to bring back?
The Founding Fathers understood that power is dangerous and corrupting, which is why they tried to limit the federal government strictly and have as many checks and balances as possible. Sadly, 250 years later, most Americans have a knee-jerk reaction to crises of saying, “the government needs to fix this problem.” The great Americans of past eras faced their own problems, but we expect bureaucracy and politicians to come swooping down with assistance in every situation. We need a wake-up call from Milton Friedman.